Collateral Consequences of Criminal Convictions on Deportation

1. What are the potential collateral consequences of a criminal conviction on someone’s immigration status?


There are several potential collateral consequences of a criminal conviction on someone’s immigration status. These consequences may vary depending on the specific charges and the individual’s immigration status, but some common ones include:

1. Risk of deportation: A criminal conviction, especially for certain types of crimes deemed “deportable offenses,” can result in an individual being placed in removal proceedings and potentially deported from the United States.

2. Ineligibility for certain immigration benefits: Certain criminal convictions can make an individual ineligible for certain immigration benefits, such as a green card or naturalization.

3. Inadmissibility to the US: A criminal conviction can render an individual inadmissible to the United States, meaning they may be denied entry or re-entry into the country.

4. Difficulty obtaining a visa or adjustment of status: Some criminal convictions can make it difficult for individuals to obtain a visa or adjust their status to become a lawful permanent resident.

5. Denial of citizenship application: If an individual applies for US citizenship, their past criminal record will be considered as part of the application process and may result in their citizenship being denied.

6. Limited job opportunities: Many employers conduct background checks and may be hesitant to hire applicants with a criminal record, which could limit job opportunities for individuals with a prior conviction.

7. Loss of certain rights and privileges: Depending on the severity of the crime and state laws, individuals with a criminal record may lose certain rights and privileges such as voting rights, gun ownership, or parental rights.

8. Increased scrutiny by immigration authorities: Even minor offenses can result in increased scrutiny by immigration authorities when applying for visas or other immigration benefits.

9. Detainment or mandatory reporting obligations: Some criminal convictions may trigger mandatory detention by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) or require law enforcement agencies to report non-citizens to ICE upon release from prison.

10. Negative impact on future immigration cases: A criminal conviction can have a negative impact on any future immigration cases an individual may have, even if they have since completed their sentence or had the conviction expunged from their record.

It is important to note that the consequences of a criminal conviction on immigration status can be severe and long-lasting, and it is crucial for individuals facing criminal charges to seek legal counsel from both a criminal defense attorney and an immigration attorney.

2. How does a criminal conviction affect immigration proceedings?

A criminal conviction can have a significant impact on immigration proceedings, and may result in serious consequences such as deportation or denial of immigration benefits. The actual impact will depend on various factors, including the type and severity of the crime, the individual’s immigration status, and the laws and policies of the country in question.

Generally, any non-citizen who is convicted of a crime may be subject to removal from the country. This includes both legal permanent residents (green card holders) and undocumented immigrants. Non-immigrants, such as those on tourist or student visas, may also face removal if they are convicted of certain crimes.

Additionally, some criminal convictions can make a non-citizen ineligible for certain immigration benefits, such as asylum or citizenship. For example, certain crimes deemed to be aggravated felonies under immigration law can make an individual automatically ineligible for many forms of relief or protection from removal.

3. Can a green card holder be deported for a criminal conviction?
Yes, a green card holder (legal permanent resident) can be deported for a criminal conviction. Under U.S. law, any non-citizen who is convicted of certain crimes or offenses may be considered “deportable” and subject to removal from the country.

The types of crimes that can make a green card holder deportable include:

– Aggravated felonies: These are serious crimes that are considered particularly heinous under U.S. law. They include offenses such as murder, rape, drug trafficking, and certain theft offenses.
– Crimes involving moral turpitude (CIMTs): These are offenses that involve dishonesty or immoral conduct, such as fraud or theft. A CIMT conviction can make someone deportable if it was committed within five years after admission to the U.S., and punishable by at least one year in prison.
– Controlled substance violations: Any conviction related to illegal drugs could result in deportation for a green card holder.
– Firearm offenses: Non-citizens convicted of certain firearm or weapons offenses may be considered deportable under U.S. law.

It is important for green card holders to be aware of the potential immigration consequences of any criminal conviction, and to seek the advice of an immigration attorney if they are facing criminal charges.

4. Can a criminal record prevent someone from obtaining a visa or becoming a citizen?

Yes, a criminal record can prevent someone from obtaining a visa or becoming a citizen. The U.S. government has strict requirements for individuals seeking visas or citizenship, and a criminal record can be grounds for denial.

For example, non-citizens applying for visas may be deemed inadmissible if they have been convicted of certain crimes, have committed multiple crimes, or are deemed to be a security threat to the country.

Similarly, non-citizens applying for naturalization (citizenship) may be denied if they have committed certain crimes or have a pattern of criminal behavior. Additionally, applicants must demonstrate good moral character to become citizens, and past criminal activity may impact this determination.

It is important for individuals with criminal records who are seeking visas or naturalization to consult with an immigration attorney before submitting their application.

5. Can someone with a conviction travel internationally?
Traveling internationally with a conviction can be complicated and may depend on various factors including the type of conviction and the laws and policies of the country you are traveling to.

Some countries may deny entry to individuals with certain types of convictions, while others may require special documentation or additional screening at the border. It is important to research the specific entry requirements for your destination before traveling.

In some cases, individuals with convictions may also need to obtain travel waivers or clearance from their probation officer before leaving the country. Failure to comply with these requirements could result in consequences such as revocation of probation or denial of re-entry into the U.S.

If you are unsure about whether your conviction will impact your ability to travel, it is best to consult with an immigration attorney for specific guidance and advice.

3. Are there certain criminal convictions that can result in automatic deportation?


Yes, certain criminal convictions can result in automatic deportation. These include:

1. Aggravated felonies: These are serious crimes such as murder, drug trafficking, and certain types of fraud that can result in immediate deportation.

2. Crimes of moral turpitude: These are offenses that involve dishonesty or depravity, such as theft, forgery, or child abuse.

3. Drug-related offenses: Convictions for drug possession, distribution or trafficking can result in deportation.

4. Firearms offenses: Convictions for crimes involving firearms can lead to deportation.

5. Domestic violence offenses: Certain domestic violence convictions can result in deportation.

6. Immigration violations: Any violation of immigration laws, such as entering the country illegally or overstaying a visa, can lead to deportation.

It is important to note that immigration laws and policies are subject to change and what may result in automatic deportation today may not necessarily do so in the future. It is always best to consult with an experienced immigration lawyer for specific guidance on your situation.

4. Can a non-citizen who has been convicted of a crime still receive residency status?

Yes, non-citizens who have been convicted of a crime may still be eligible for residency status, depending on the type and severity of the crime committed. Each country has its own laws and immigration policies that dictate the eligibility criteria for obtaining residency. In some cases, a criminal record may disqualify an individual from obtaining residency status, while in others it may not necessarily be a barrier. It is important to thoroughly research the immigration laws and requirements of the country in question before applying for residency.

5. How does the immigration status of a non-citizen change after a criminal conviction?


The immigration status of a non-citizen can change after a criminal conviction in several ways:

1. Deportation or Removal Proceedings: Non-citizens who are convicted of certain crimes may be deported or removed from the country. This means they will be forced to leave the United States and may not be allowed to return.

2. Inadmissibility: A criminal conviction can make a non-citizen inadmissible, meaning they may not be able to enter or re-enter the United States even if they have a valid visa.

3. Loss of Visa or Green Card: Some non-citizens who hold visas or green cards may lose their status if they are convicted of certain crimes. They may also have their visa revoked if it is found that they committed fraud in obtaining it.

4. Limited Eligibility for Immigration Benefits: Certain types of criminal convictions can make a non-citizen ineligible for certain immigration benefits, such as citizenship, asylum, or permanent residency.

5. Immigration Hold or Detention: Depending on the severity of the crime and the potential threat to public safety, non-citizens may be subject to an immigration hold or detention while their case is being reviewed by immigration authorities.

It’s important for non-citizens facing criminal charges to consult with an experienced immigration attorney to understand how their immigration status may be affected and what steps they can take to protect their rights and future in the United States.

6. What types of criminal convictions are considered aggravated felonies and can lead to deportation?


An aggravated felony is a type of criminal conviction that can lead to deportation for non-citizen immigrants. These felonies are considered the most serious offenses and typically involve violence or significant harm to others. The types of criminal convictions that may be considered aggravated felonies vary depending on the country, but some common examples include:

1. Murder or manslaughter
2. Drug trafficking (including possession with intent to sell)
3. Sexual abuse of a minor
4. Rape or sexual assault
5. Trafficking in firearms or explosive devices
6. Fraud or theft involving over $10,000
7. Kidnapping or hostage-taking
8. Racketeering (organized crime)
9. Treason or espionage against the government
10. Aggravated identity theft

It’s important to note that these are just some examples and there may be other offenses that could be considered aggravated felonies depending on the specific circumstances and laws of the country in question. Additionally, certain misdemeanors may also be considered aggravated felonies if they involve violent behavior or significant harm to others.

It’s also worth noting that a criminal conviction does not necessarily guarantee deportation, as there are certain mitigating factors that may be taken into consideration by immigration officials, such as the length of time since the offense was committed and any rehabilitation efforts made by the individual.

If you have been convicted of an aggravated felony and are facing deportation proceedings, it’s important to seek legal counsel from an experienced immigration attorney who can help evaluate your case and provide guidance on potential defense options.

7. Can a non-citizen be deported even if their criminal conviction has been pardoned?


Yes, it is possible for a non-citizen to be deported even if their criminal conviction has been pardoned. This is because a pardon does not erase the fact that the person was convicted of a crime, and immigration law allows for deportation of non-citizens who have been convicted of certain crimes. In some cases, the pardon may help in halting or delaying deportation proceedings, but it does not guarantee protection from deportation.

8. Are there any exceptions to the deportation rule for criminal convictions?


Yes, there are exceptions to the deportation rule for criminal convictions. These exceptions include cancellation of removal, asylum or withholding of removal, and relief under the Convention Against Torture. Additionally, certain crimes may not make an individual removable depending on the specific circumstances and the immigration status of the individual. It is important to consult with an experienced immigration attorney to determine if any exceptions apply in a particular case.

9. What is the difference between removal proceedings and deportation proceedings?


Removal proceedings and deportation proceedings are two terms used in the US immigration system that refer to legal processes for the removal of an individual from the country. While they are often used interchangeably, there are some key differences between the two.

1. Definition:
Removal proceedings and deportation proceedings both refer to the legal process by which an individual is ordered to leave the United States. However, removal proceedings specifically apply to individuals who are inadmissible to the US (i.e. have not been legally admitted) or who have violated their immigration status, while deportation refers to individuals who have already been admitted to the US but are being removed due to a violation of immigration laws.

2. Authority:
The authority for removal proceedings lies with US Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS), while deportation falls under the jurisdiction of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). Both agencies fall under the umbrella of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS).

3. Individuals affected:
Removal proceedings can be initiated against any non-citizen residing in the US who is found to be inadmissible or who has violated their status. Deportation, on the other hand, applies only to individuals who have legally entered the US but have subsequently violated immigration laws.

4. Grounds for removal/deportation:
There are various grounds that can lead to an individual being placed in removal or deportation proceedings, such as criminal convictions, overstaying a visa, or illegally entering the country. In general, deportation tends to involve more serious violations of immigration law than removal.

5. Process:
In both types of proceedings, a Notice to Appear (NTA) will be issued by USCIS or ICE which outlines why an individual is being placed in removal/deportation proceedings and provides information on their hearing date and location. The main difference lies in how these hearings are conducted – removal hearings are primarily administrative proceedings before an Immigration Judge at an EOIR court, while deportation hearings take place before a federal judge in a federal district court.

6. Possible outcomes:
The ultimate outcome of both proceedings is the individual’s removal from the US. However, there are some differences in the potential outcomes. In removal proceedings, individuals may have more options for relief from removal, such as seeking asylum or cancellation of removal. In deportation cases, individuals may be subject to mandatory detention and have fewer options for relief.

In summary, removal proceedings and deportation proceedings are both legal processes for the removal of an individual from the US, but they differ in their definition, authority, affected individuals, grounds for removal/deportation, process, and possible outcomes. It is important to consult with an immigration attorney if you are facing either type of proceeding to understand your rights and options.

10. Are there any defenses that can be used to prevent deportation due to a criminal conviction?


Yes, there are a few potential defenses that can be used to prevent deportation due to a criminal conviction. These include:

1. Procedural errors: If there were procedural errors in the criminal case, such as violations of the defendant’s constitutional rights, this can be used as a defense to prevent deportation.

2. Lack of evidence: If the conviction was based on insufficient or unreliable evidence, it may not meet the legal standard required for removal.

3. Ineffective assistance of counsel: If the defendant’s criminal defense attorney did not provide effective representation that resulted in a wrongful conviction, this may be used as a defense against deportation.

4. Adjustment of Status: In some cases, an individual may be eligible to adjust their immigration status and become a lawful permanent resident instead of facing deportation.

5. Asylum or refugee status: If an individual fears persecution in their home country due to race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group, they may be eligible for asylum or refugee status which would prevent deportation.

6. Family ties: If an individual has family members who are U.S citizens or lawful permanent residents and can demonstrate that their removal would cause extreme hardship to these family members, this may be a defense against deportation.

7. Rehabilitation/cancellation of removal: Some individuals with certain types of convictions may be eligible for rehabilitation or cancellation of removal if they can show that they have reformed and are unlikely to commit future crimes.

It is important to note that each case is unique and the availability and success of these defenses will depend on individual circumstances. It is best to consult with an experienced immigration attorney for guidance on the best approach for your specific case.

11. Does the severity of the criminal conviction affect whether or not someone can be deported?


Yes, the severity of a criminal conviction can significantly impact whether or not someone can be deported. In most cases, non-citizens convicted of serious crimes such as murder, rape, or drug trafficking can be deported from the United States. On the other hand, minor offenses such as traffic violations may not result in deportation. However, there are also certain “aggravated felonies” that can lead to deportation even if they are not considered serious crimes under state law. The specific laws and regulations surrounding deportation for criminal convictions can be complex and vary depending on individual circumstances and immigration status.

12. Is it possible to fight deportation due to a criminal conviction?


Yes, it is possible to fight deportation due to a criminal conviction. Some options for fighting deportation in this situation include:

1. Challenging the criminal conviction: If there are grounds for appeal or if the conviction can be overturned, it may prevent deportation from happening.

2. Applying for post-conviction relief: This can include motions to vacate, set aside, or correct the criminal conviction. If successful, it could also prevent deportation.

3. Seeking a pardon or clemency: A pardon from the governor or president can eliminate the immigration consequences of a criminal conviction.

4. Filing for cancellation of removal: This option is available for Lawful Permanent Residents (LPRs) who have been convicted of certain crimes and have lived in the US consistently for at least 7 years.

5. Applying for asylum, withholding of removal, or Convention Against Torture (CAT) protection: These options may be available if a person fears persecution or torture in their home country as a result of their criminal record.

6. Arguing against “aggravated felony” classification: Certain convictions are classified as “aggravated felonies” under immigration law and can result in mandatory deportation without any possibility of relief. However, there may be arguments that the crime does not meet the definition of an aggravated felony.

It is important to consult with an experienced immigration attorney to determine the best course of action in fighting deportation due to a criminal conviction. Each case is unique and requires individual analysis.

13. How long can someone be detained before being deported due to a criminal conviction?


The length of time someone can be detained before being deported due to a criminal conviction depends on several factors, including the seriousness of the crime and the individual’s immigration status. For permanent residents, deportation proceedings typically begin after they have served their sentence for the criminal offense. In most cases, this means they will be detained until their sentence is complete.

For non-permanent residents, the timeline may vary depending on the severity of the crime and whether they are eligible for bond or parole. For example, if an individual is eligible for bond and is able to pay it, they may be released while awaiting deportation proceedings.

In some cases, individuals with serious criminal convictions may face expedited removal without any detention time, particularly if they are deemed a threat to public safety or national security.

Overall, there is no set time limit for how long someone can be detained before being deported due to a criminal conviction. It will depend on individual circumstances and applicable laws.

14. Are there any options for relief from deportation if someone has been convicted of a crime?


Yes, there are several potential options for relief from deportation for someone who has been convicted of a crime. These include:

1. Cancellation of Removal: This is an option for non-permanent residents who have been in the United States for at least 10 years and can demonstrate good moral character and that their removal would result in exceptional and extremely unusual hardship to a U.S. citizen or permanent resident spouse, parent, or child.

2. Adjustment of Status: If the individual has a family member who is a U.S. citizen or permanent resident and can sponsor them for a green card, they may be eligible to adjust their status from non-immigrant to immigrant, which could potentially stop the deportation proceedings.

3. Asylum/Withholding of Removal: If the person fears returning to their home country due to persecution based on race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group, they may be able to apply for asylum or withholding of removal.

4. U visa: If the individual was a victim of certain crimes and cooperated with law enforcement in the investigation or prosecution of those crimes, they may be eligible for a U visa status which would grant them temporary legal status and possibly lead to permanent residency.

5. Deferred Action: This is a discretionary option where Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agrees to temporarily suspend deportation proceedings against an individual.

6. Temporary Protected Status (TPS): If the person comes from a country that has been designated by the U.S government as unsafe due to conditions such as war or natural disaster, they may be eligible for TPS which allows them to stay in the U.S temporarily.

It’s important to note that eligibility requirements vary for each type of relief and not all individuals will qualify. It’s best to consult with an immigration attorney for specific guidance on which option would be most appropriate in your situation.

15. Does the length of time since the criminal conviction affect the risk of deportation?

Generally yes. The longer it has been since the criminal conviction, the less likely it is that deportation will occur. However, this is not always the case as certain serious offenses can still result in deportation even if they occurred many years ago.

16. What options are available if someone is facing deportation due to a criminal conviction?


1. Requesting a Stay of Removal: If the individual’s criminal conviction is the sole basis for their deportation, they may request a stay of removal from the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). A stay of removal means that their deportation will be temporarily put on hold.

2. Applying for Cancellation of Removal: This option is available to those who have been living in the United States for at least 10 years, have good moral character, and can prove that their deportation would result in exceptional and extremely unusual hardship to their US citizen or permanent resident spouse, parent or child.

3. Seeking Asylum: If an individual fears persecution in their home country based on race, religion, nationality, political opinion or membership in a particular social group, they can apply for asylum. This will stop the deportation proceedings while their case is being reviewed.

4. Applying for Withholding of Removal: Similar to asylum, an individual can apply for withholding of removal if they fear persecution in their home country. However, this option requires a higher burden of proof than asylum.

5. Pursuing Adjustment of Status: In certain cases where an individual has a family member who is a US citizen or permanent resident willing to sponsor them, they may be able to adjust their status from someone facing deportation to a lawful permanent resident.

6. Seeking Relief under the Convention Against Torture (CAT): If there is evidence that an individual will be tortured if returned to their home country, they may be eligible for relief under CAT.

7. Filing an Appeal: If the individual disagrees with the decision made by the immigration judge or appeals officer regarding their deportation case, they can file an appeal with the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) within 30 days.

8. Applying for Temporary Protected Status (TPS): Individuals from certain countries facing crisis situations such as armed conflict or natural disasters may be eligible for Temporary Protected Status which allows them to remain in the US.

9. Applying for Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA): Individuals who arrived in the US as children and meet certain eligibility requirements may be able to apply for DACA which provides temporary protection from deportation and work authorization.

10. Seeking Help from a Pro Bono Immigration Attorney: Nonprofit organizations, private law firms and law schools may offer free legal services to individuals facing deportation due to criminal convictions.

11. Seeking a Pardon: In some cases, an individual may be eligible for a pardon from a governor or president which can potentially stop their deportation.

12. Requesting Prosecutorial Discretion: ICE has the discretion to prioritize certain cases over others and determine whether to proceed with deportation or exercise prosecutorial discretion in favor of the individual.

13. Seeking Judicial Review: If all other options have been exhausted, an individual can file a request for judicial review with the federal courts.

14. Voluntary Departure: If none of the above options are available, an individual may voluntarily leave the US before their court date, which can have fewer consequences than being ordered removed by an immigration judge.

15. Filing Motion to Reopen or Motion to Reconsider: An individual can file a motion to reopen their case if new evidence has become available that was not previously considered by the court. A motion to reconsider requests that the court re-evaluate its decision based on existing evidence.

16. Seeking International Protection through Other Countries: In rare cases, individuals facing deportation may seek protection by applying for asylum or refugee status in other countries that are signatories of international treaties such as the 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees.

17. Are there any restrictions on where someone can be deported to due to a criminal conviction?

Yes, there are restrictions on where someone can be deported to due to a criminal conviction. Generally, an individual can only be deported to their country of citizenship or to a country where they have legal permanent residence status. This is because the receiving country must agree to take the deportee back and provide them with appropriate legal and social support. Additionally, deportation may be limited for individuals who would face persecution or torture in the country they are being sent back to.

18. Can someone with a criminal conviction be granted asylum or relief from removal proceedings?

Yes, it is possible for someone with a criminal conviction to be granted asylum or relief from removal proceedings. However, having a criminal conviction may make it more difficult to obtain asylum or other forms of relief. It ultimately depends on the specific circumstances of the case and the discretion of the immigration judge or asylum officer handling the case.

19. Does the country of citizenship affect whether or not someone will be deported due to a criminal conviction?


Yes, the country of citizenship can affect whether or not someone will be deported due to a criminal conviction. Some countries have extradition treaties with the United States that allow for the deportation of individuals who have committed certain crimes within their borders. Other factors that may influence whether or not someone is deported include the severity and nature of the crime, the person’s immigration status, and any prior criminal history.

20. What is the process for appealing a deportation order due to a criminal conviction?


The process for appealing a deportation order due to a criminal conviction may vary depending on the specific circumstances of the case, but generally it involves the following steps:

1. Consult with an immigration attorney: It is recommended to seek legal advice from an experienced immigration attorney who can assess your case and provide guidance on the best course of action.

2. Determine eligibility for relief: Your attorney will review your criminal record and immigration status to determine if you are eligible for any form of relief from deportation, such as cancellation of removal, waiver of inadmissibility, or adjustment of status.

3. File a Notice of Appeal: If you have been issued a final order of deportation by an immigration judge or the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA), you must file a Notice of Appeal within 30 days.

4. Prepare and file briefs: After filing the Notice of Appeal, you or your attorney must submit a written brief outlining the legal arguments for why the deportation order should be reversed or modified. The government will also have an opportunity to submit a brief in response.

5. Attend oral argument: In some cases, there may be an opportunity for you or your attorney to present oral arguments before an appellate court.

6. Await decision: The appellate court will issue a decision either upholding the deportation order or granting relief from removal. If relief is granted, your case will be sent back to the lower court for further proceedings.

7. Consider further appeals: If you are not satisfied with the decision of the appellate court, you may have the option to file further appeals with higher courts, such as federal circuit courts or even the United States Supreme Court.

Overall, appealing a deportation order due to a criminal conviction can be a complex and lengthy process. It is crucial to work closely with an experienced immigration attorney throughout each step to ensure that all necessary paperwork is filed accurately and on time.